Monday, November 16, 2026

Weekly Margin 2026, W46: The Panic Defense, The Blue Violinist Over West End Avenue

11/09/26: The Panic Defense
What: Writer/director Sam Affoumado's new docu-drama examining the "gay panic" and "trans panic" legal strategies.
And? full review here.

Robert Maisonett as Catcaller, Fola Walker as Maxine, and 
Careem Joy as James. Photo courtesy of the production.



What: Debbie Goodstein's new play, a modern-day adaptation of Fiddler on the Roof, explores an upper west side Jewish family in which each adult child has chosen a partner at some divide from their parents' core tenets: their daughter marries a gentile, one son makes aliyah and raises his family in a kibbutz, another son is celebrating his engagement to a man, and now the third son has brought home a keffiyeh-wearing antizionist girlfriend. In the months leading up to the wedding (and, unbeknownst to them, October 7, 2023), tensions run high as the family members struggle to communicate across chasms of core beliefs.
And? It has a lot in common with The Ally, produced two years ago at The Public; by which I mean, it's a bit heavy-handed, the dialogue tips readily into didactic talking points over character development, and the story takes place in the month or months leading up to October 7th (though it's worth saying that The Ally was originally written before the pogrom). So yes, some of it gets a bit ... I've already had these conversations, but Goodstein works to give balanced breath to the range of opinions on the complexity that is the Middle East and Israeli-Palestinian relations, rather than just the extremist positions. And once the pogrom happens, clear lines are drawn by playwright and characters over what is an appropriate response. There's a lot of endearing here: the parents' love for their children; gentile husband Vinny's enthusiastic embrace of the Jewish culture and every piece of Yiddish he can pick up (he's a bit of a cliche, but still very charming); the engaged couple Joseph and Sami, curled around each other while gently pushing back when the two extremes of the debate taking over the family veer into absolutism; the earnest devotion of Yitzhak to his home in Israel and to his profound Judaism (Etai Benson's performance in this role is particularly powerful). Lauren Helpern's scenic design is lovely, too: a backdrop with an impressionistic view of the city, an homage to the titular Chagall painting (a print of which figures prominently in the parents' home and, of course, evokes Fiddler on the Roof as aggressively as the script does); the textured exposed brick of the back wall turning wavy, flat, and more abstract as it edges forward toward the audience, bending reality into something within the imagination.

I also want to note this: at this point, theater-goers in New York are accustomed to cursory bag checks and metal detectors as they enter a theater. But this past year I've encountered very intense screening--thorough wanding, emptying of pockets, every-compartment bag check--and these have been only at plays that involve Israel. It's a damning statement on where the culture is at the moment. The Band's Visit's entry had no such thoroughness, and that was less than a decade ago. It's not quite as intense as the armed guards screening every single vehicle entering a lot for Jewish community centers and schools (which is horrifyingly normal), but it's looking toward that horizon.

Adam Heller as Abe, Mike Labbadia as Vinny, Lauriel
Friedman as Rachel, and Barbara Walsh as Dina.
Photo by Jeremy Daniel.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Margin Notes: The Panic Defense

The Panic Defense
Juan C. Ortiz as Brianna/Benny and
Keith R. Beck as Daniel.
Photo courtesy of the production.

Seen on: Monday, 11/09/26.

Plot and Background
Writer/director Sam Affoumado's new docu-drama examines the "gay panic" and "trans panic" legal strategies. Focusing on four specific murder victims, each killed either for their gender identity/expression or their homosexuality, Affoumado attempts to give voice to these people who were silenced forever. Though inspired by docu-plays like The Laramie Project and The Exonerated, this play eschews verbatim text for the imagined senses of selves of the four real-life victims, as well as brief reenactments of the moments leading up to their murders.

Thoughts:

The press release and auteur statement discuss an examination of legal strategies that weaponize prejudices against queer identities in courtrooms, and indeed places the audience in the position of jury, with the two attorneys addressing the audience first to set the stage for us. What follows, though, is less testimony than character study. The four victims--Brianna, Mike, Travis, and Maxine--have alternating monologues, all still addressing the audience directly, as they explain who they are, who they would like to be, and what they want out of life. Each narrative ultimately shows the lead-up to the murders, but does not end there, returning to the characters themselves. Affoumado's true intent, stated goal aside, is to show the real complex humanity of these people before they get flattened out by defense attorneys into vaguely menacing symbols, threatening enough to provoke their attackers into violence. Though we do eventually hear brief testimony from each attacker, their victims remain present to contradict the lies told about them and about their final moments. In the play's epilogue we learn the ultimate sentencing of the murderers (ranging from life imprisonment, to a few years' sentencing, to a not guilty verdict), hear final moments of hope from each victim, and then the production honors victims from this past year with a slideshow of their photos, names, and date and nature of their deaths. The list is damningly long.

Monday, November 9, 2026

Weekly Margin 2026, W45: School Girls, Love Me, Downstate, A Ghost in Your Ear, The Visitors, In Clay

11/03/26: School Girls; Or, The African Mean Girls Play
What: The long-awaited Broadway production of Jocelyn Bioh's celebrated play, first mounted Off-Broadway in 2017 by MCC. Now hosted by MTC, this revival production returns us to Ghana in 1986 as a cadre of teenagers anticipate a pageant that could launch one of them into stardom by becoming Miss Ghana.
And? This is an exuberant production. It definitely feels bigger than the 2017 one, in many ways. The performance space is bigger, of course, but it's also brighter, airier: this version of the school is clearly better funded, as evident in both the scenic and costume design. The humor feels bigger, but perhaps that's because it's aimed at a bigger audience. The production also, of course, features bigger names this time around, including a Tony winner and several nominees (it does also feature a number of young actresses making their Broadway debut, which I love to see). Denée Benton gives a delicious turn as Paulina, the school's resident Regina George: elegant, casually cruel, aggressively masking her insecurities. Jasmine Amy Rogers as her foil, new girl Ericka, brings her signature sweetness to the role, which makes her climactic turn into a mirroring cruelty all the more satisfying. As the presiding Headmistress Francis, Heather Alicia Simms has tremendous gravitas and warmth as she is forced to make impossible decisions regarding the future of her charges. It's excellent to see this play again, though I'm still navigating my thoughts on the look and feel of this production over MCC's.

Denée Benton as Paulina, Jordan Rice as Mercy, Nia Otchere-Sarfo
as Gifty, Lucia Aremu as Ama, Erin Morton as Nana, and
Heather Alicia Simms as Headmistress Francis.
Photo by Matthew Murphy.


11/05/26: Love Me
What: Deaf West and Soho Rep present Drew Michael's solo show, a mix of standup and memoir about his struggles to learn how to love himself and to acknowledge his loss of hearing.
And? It needs some editing, but goddamn what a finish. Drew Michael knows how to stick the landing for sure. The sound and headphone concept, as designed by Daniel Kluger and executed in collaboration with Listen Technologies and Renaissance Recording, NYC, is really quite something. The audience is issued headphones, which we wear for the majority of the performance, and through it we hear not only the intrusive (and deeply disruptive) thoughts of Drew, but also the muffled sound of all speakers around him: we are able to experience, even if only for an hour, what it is to try to exist in a hearing world that doesn't attempt to accommodate Deaf individuals. The release, then, as the piece winds down (and it's powerful enough that I don't want to spoil it), is immensely satisfying and moving, and worth the visit.




Monday, November 2, 2026

Weekly Margin 2026, W44: Everybody Rise!, Horsegirl & Cowdaddy

 10/27/26: Everybody Rise!
What: Steven Carl McCasland's cabaret, a celebration of beloved female characters in the musical theater canon (as well as Steven's birthday).
And? Disclosure: Steven is a good friend of mine. But I think I'm still correct in saying this was a marvelous night. The performance was originally scheduled to take place about a month earlier, but had to be postponed due to the rainstorm and flooding taking over the city (in this case, a literal rain date performance). Not the worse for wear, we still delivered Steven a sold-out audience. Or perhaps he delivered us. McCasland has a strong voice and fearless persona, and you can hear and see his joy in performing in every moment of this cabaret, as well as his deep affection for these songs. His set list is a mix of standards, interesting mash-ups, a few tongue-in-cheek lyric rewrites, lesser-known works, and a (borrowed) gently-orchestrated "Everything's Coming Up Roses." And I don't believe it's a spoiler to note that his encore is the song from which the title of his night comes: "The Ladies Who Lunch," from Company.

Highlights of the evening:
  • The smirking sweetness of Sondheim's "The Boy From ..." with perfect delivery of the titular's boy's origin, slightly different on each repeat.
  • The out and out belt on Smash's "They Just Keep Moving the Line."
  • "Times Like This" (Lucky Stiff) drawing big teardrops from me, paired with the equally heartbreaking "Far From the Home I Love" (Fiddler on the Roof).
  • And then immediately after those two, the brassy yelling of "Murray!" as he launched into "Just One Step" from Songs for a New World.



Streaming Theater

Monday, October 26, 2026

Weekly Margin 2026, W43: The Ask, Bitcoin Bad Boy, Fish

10/20/26: The Ask
What: A new two-hander from Matthew Freeman about a meeting between a fundraiser for the ACLU and a wealthy donor who has been reconsidering her contributions based on what she perceives as shifting priorities incompatible with the organization's core mission.
And? The main crux here is the generational (and ultimately cultural) divide between a Boomer liberal and a Gen Z leftie, both believing passionately in the mission of the organization but at odds for the priorities of advocacy within that. And it's not that it's an uninteresting topic--the question of past fights won or lost weighed against current battles still in the trenches is one worth exploring. But it's not explored in the most interesting manner here. There's not a tremendous amount of insight offered for the full lives of either character outside the broad sketches of their demographic. There's tension in how fundraiser Tanner has to shape their responses to donor Greta, cognizant the entire time that hundreds of thousands of dollars are on the line for how this conversation concludes. But it's not really enough when I'm not invested in the characters, and neither side of the argument is going to effectively win over an audience member on the other side of the debate. There's some empathy to be gained, in understanding how each character believes what they believe (and very fine performances from Marilu Henner and especially Shannon Purser), but it's not enough and ultimately just feels like I'm reading a well-structured (and respectful) comments section.

Marilu Henner as Greta and Shannon Purser as Tanner.
Photo by Joan Marcus.



10/21/26: Bitcoin Bad Boy
What: As part of Chain Theatre's Factory Series, Inferno presents Ben Schiller's sequel to the 2024 Happenstance. Newly released crypto-coder Charlie must decide between embracing the more lucrative and corrupt side of cryptocurrency or insist on transparency and freedom.
And? full review here

Foreground: Gianna Hoffman as Sallie.
Background: Jack Orrico as Dan and Gloria
Sangirardi Jung as Barbara. Photo courtesy
of the production.


10/22/26: Fish
What: Melis Aker's play about a teenage girl who, trying to bypass her mother's efforts to see if her brother was recruited into a terrorist organization, begins catfishing ISIS members into sending her money.
And? The unfolding narrative is interesting, even if the performances are, by and large, not subtle (and the accent work unfortunately inconsistent). Emma Finckel's scenic design, the shiny tile panels of a swimming pool that turn strikingly modular depending on scene location, is excellent, simple, and smart.

Yasmin Ranz-Lind as Karya. Photo by Joan Marcus.