a repeat visit
3/27/25: Love Life
What: City Center Encores! presents the 1948 Kurt Weill/Alan Jay Lerner musical about an unhappy couple whose children cause them to look back on their relationship to see where it went wrong--with each time we visit them being a different point in America's history, even though the four family members do not age, spanning from 1791 to 1948, when the show itself premiered. Does that sound weird? It kind of is, but it's easy enough to follow in the moment.
And? This is a classic example of how valuable the Encores! series is: a show that is not often revived (in this case, there isn't even a surviving cast album), presented with full orchestra and high-caliber talent, to give new voice to the score. And often with this sort of thing, we can see why that show isn't often revived. Though this production ran for a year, it's rather unfocused in its concept (though perhaps with a stronger director than we have here, that focus would be more precise: there's a clear framing lens of vaudeville acts around this archetypal nuclear family, though I missed the consistent flavor that would have made that clear enough that the Pippin-esque finale didn't feel so far out of left field.
The family themselves don't really become people I invest in, but I think this show must have hit very very differently in 1948. My dad writes about the mythologizing of America in musicals like Oklahoma!, The Music Man, and Guys and Dolls. He also writes about the marriage trope, wherein the central couple's union represents the cohesion of community as a whole. This musical is a prime candidate for both those lenses--a look back at America's history through the frame of this family, but even more so, the nation's precarious state of maintaining unity in the wake of the Second World War, which had ended only three years previously (I wonder now why there wasn't a chapter in the show that took place during the Civil War, but then we probably know the answer to that one). America was very divided over this war--whether to enter the fray or not (not even touching on how many supported Hitler's campaign), and then the devastating outcome of our use of nuclear force. Is this the sort of thing a nation can survive and still feel united? Though the musical itself doesn't address any wars (the closest it gets to commentary of any sort are Susan's campaign for the right to vote, and a scene set during the Prohibition Era), it is meant to present the couple with the same degree of uncertainty. Indeed, their final moment is the two of them carefully reaching across a tightrope to each other, trying to hold their balance and hopefully hold each other as well. It's not just the future of their family--it's the future of our nation's soul.
So I can see what's interesting about this show, conceptually (and it must have been something with its original Michael Kidd choreo!) without having particularly gotten a lot emotionally out of the Encores! staging. That being said, the music is lush (even if Alan Jay Lerner is outed here as recycling a lyric and song concept from this show later for Gigi), and my god, the voices. Brian Stokes Mitchell, always a powerful voice, infuses everything he does with such warmth and joy (even back in 2020 when he stood at his open window every night to sing "The Impossible Dream" to anyone walking by) that you can't help but love him. Kate Baldwin matches him for warmth and powerful vocals. And then the ensemble! Stunning voices and harmonies throughout, in a score that really does make a point to feature many of its players. John Edwards, as both the Hobo and the M.C., has an extraordinary baritone and it's a treat to hear him sing.
Kate Baldwin and Brian Stokes Mitchell as Susan Cooper and Sam Cooper, with the ensemble. Photo by Joan Marcus. |
Streaming Theater-Related Content I Watched
- National Theatre at Home's Nye.
- Wilma Theater's The Half-God of Rainfall.