Tuesday, December 16, 2025
Best Theater of 2025: Another Year End, Another List
Monday, December 16, 2024
Best Theater of 2024: Here We Are Again
Wednesday, December 13, 2023
Best Theater of 2023: Well, we survived, I guess
![]() |
| The company of The Coast Starlight. Photo by T. Charles Erikson. |
![]() |
| Ben Turner and Jonathan Nyati as Salar and Mohammed in The Jungle. Photo by Marc Brenner. |
![]() |
| Hiran Abeysekera and puppeteers as Pi and Richard Parker in Life of Pi (London run). Photo by Johan Persson. |
![]() |
| Yasen Peyankov and James Vincent Meredith as Nikolai and Isaac in Describe the Night. Photo by Michael Brosilow. |
![]() |
| Debo Balogun and Mi Kang as Paul Emmanuel and Lucy Snowe in Villette. Photo by Liz Lauren. |
![]() |
| Derek Christopher Murphy and Max Kantor as Finch and Hawk in Rough Trade. Photo by Hunter Canning. |
![]() |
| Lorna Courtney, Betsy Wolfe, Justin David Sullivan, and Melanie La Barrie as Juliet, April, May, and Angelique in & Juliet. Photo by Matthew Murphy. |
![]() |
| Mary Beth Fisher and Bubba Weiler as Peg and Ryan in Swing State. Photo by Liz Lauren. |
![]() |
| Cover art for Nosferatu, a 3D Symphony of Horror. |
Friday, December 16, 2022
Yesterday is Done: Best Theater of 2022
![]() |
| Molly Ranson, Jeff Seymour, and Yair Ben-Dor as Molly, Charles, and Daniel in Prayer for the French Republic. Photo by Matt Murphy |
![]() |
| Kristolyn Lloyd, Elijah Jones, and Andrea Patterson as Sara, Abner, and LuAnne in Confederates. Photo by Monique Carboni. |
![]() |
| Will Brill and Kyle Beltran as Ryan and Keith in A Case for the Existence of God. Photo by Emilio Madrid. |
![]() |
| David Strathairn as Jan Karski in Remember This: The Lesson of Jan Karski. Photo by Teresa Castracane. |
![]() |
| Philip Estrera as Catch with Allison Kelly, Adam Boggs McDonald, and Rheanna Atendido as the Sirens in Monstress. Photo by Al Foote III. |
![]() |
| Top: Jenn Kidwell, Mel Krodman, and Jess Conda in Those With 2 Clocks. Bottom: Milo Cramer in School Pictures. Both photos by Johanna Austin. |
![]() |
| Ben Platt, center, as Leo Frank, with the company of Parade. Photo by Joan Marcus. |
Tuesday, December 14, 2021
Onstage and Streaming: My Top Theater for 2021
Tuesday, December 29, 2020
2020 Theater: The Year of Streaming (with a small handful of live theater at the top)
![]() |
| The closest I've come to Times Square since March 12th. Photo by Zelda Knapp. |
Raise a glass for Terrence McNally, Mark Blum, Adam Schlesinger, William Wolf, Brian Dennehy, Shirley Knight, Peter Hunt, Bernard Gersten, Larry Kramer, Nick Cordero, Brent Carver, Howell Binkley, Herbert Kretzmer, Israel Horowitz, Ann Reinking, Rebecca Luker. For UCB, for Shetler Studios, for the Secret Theatre, for Simple Studios, for the Creek and the Cave. For Frozen and for Then She Fell.
Raise a glass for the fact that we still don't know when theater can safely return in the States, and what will be left of us when it does. (Also randomly, they never got around to having the Tony Awards, even though they released the nominations in October. The Obies, Drama Desks, Lortel, and Antonyo awards were either aired online or released as a list.)
So this is my year-end post, where I list the top shows I saw this year. What do I even write about? I saw 24 shows before the shutdown on March 12th. And then since then I've seen 173 streaming theater pieces (a mixture of archive recordings, formerly recorded broadcasts, quarantine bubble productions with no audience, zoom readings, and hybrid forms of theater and film) (also I have 3-4 items left on my to-watch list for this year). Some of it has been decidedly not good. Some of it has been wonderful, poignant and uplifting. None of it is the real thing, and I still ache at the memory of kinetic energy passing between an enthusiastic audience and a vibrant production. But it's been something. I keep thinking of AJ's speech in The American President:
People want leadership, Mr. President, and in the absence of genuine leadership, they'll listen to anyone who steps up to the microphone. They want leadership. They're so thirsty for it they'll crawl through the desert toward a mirage, and when they discover there's no water, they'll drink the sand.
Replace leadership with live theater and that's where I've landed. I've drunk some sand this year. But. It hasn't all been sand. And too much of my nature is geared toward finding a glimmer of gratitude within my grief. So I've made a list of what was special this year: a smaller one for the live theater, and the rest for what I watched online. You can expect my usual cheats to get in more than just a paltry "Top Ten." It's 2020, the worst year in many of our lives, and I want to remember as much joy as I can.
Godspeed, my loves. We'll be together again.
Thursday, March 19, 2020
Weekly Margin 2020, W12: What I Didn't See, and a Memory of Such Stuff
I keep thinking I should make my usual list of the Spring season, look into ticket lotteries, rush policies, their presence on tdf. Making this list has been on my To Do calendar for a few weeks. Now it seems like a task designed to invite more heartbreak, wondering which shows are never to be.
I thought instead of looking forward into an unknowable future, and with no current theater to discuss, perhaps I should look back further.
Monday, December 16, 2019
My Picks: Best Theater of 2019
![]() |
| Andrew Scott and Sophie Thompson as Garry Essendine and Monica Reed in The Old Vic's Present Laughter. Photo by Elliott Franks. |
I had an easier time making my list this year than I normally do, but the tragic cause of that is my viewing numbers were down again, with a projected 109 unique shows, and 122 shows overall for 2019 (one show to go on Dec 28th; also, I am fully aware of just how awful I sound, complaining about seeing only 122 shows this year. Please believe that I do not take my life here for granted, or my ability to see as much theater as I do). I definitely suffered from some activity fatigue this year, partly due to the exhaustion of moving into a new apartment and all its attendant stress; this resulted in some neglect of my Off- and Off-Off- options. In any case, the list wasn't as hard to whittle down, a small mercy for a weary Zelda. But I will say this: the shows that made my top ten list? Astoundingly good theater, every one of them. And while I'm attempting to rank them this year, it's tight as anything for the top five (except Octet, which I knew would top the list when I saw it; basically the top four after Octet are all second, but in an apples and oranges and bananas and mangoes situation).
This year gave us extraordinary new takes on older works, like Erica Schmidt's schoolgirl Mac Beth, the Yiddish Fiddler on the Roof, and the Old Vic's hilarious new spin on Coward's Present Laughter. It also gave us astonishing new work that defiantly challenged expectations of what can be done in the theater, like Dave Malloy's a cappella brain explosion Octet, Michael R. Jackson's breathtaking not-autobiographical A Strange Loop, and Jeremy O. Harris's uncomfortable and gutting Slave Play. We had actual magic onstage, from Harry Potter to Derren Brown to Slava and his Snowshow (I know some of the shows I just mentioned weren't new in 2019, but Slava excepting, they were new to me in 2019, and as the old refrain goes, this is my blog, dammit).
(also, I hear people are making their Best of the Decade lists as well. That's cool, though as my friend Tyler pointed out, we technically have one more year in the decade, but also I think it would hurt my heart too much to boil a decade down to ten shows. Think of all the gems that wouldn't make the cut!)
Anyway, we had so many good shows in 2019. Here were some of the best:
Monday, December 24, 2018
Best Of ... 18 for 2018
![]() |
| The cast of Head Over Heels. Photo by Joan Marcus. |
Thursday, December 28, 2017
My Favorite Theater of 2017
![]() |
| Paul Hilton and Anna Francolini as Peter Pan and Captain Hook in Peter Pan. Photo by Steve Tanner. |
Part of why, even with a sparse autumn, the whittling was so difficult, lies in the fact that I hit a personal record this past year: 151 shows total (ho-ly merde), with 16 repeats, leaving 135 unique shows, besting last year by 24 unique shows and besting my highest year (2013) by 13.
So we should probably get started. I've had such a difficult time cutting the list down, and at this point, I don't even know how to rank them, so instead for a change of pace, I'm presenting them in chronological order of when I saw them.
Wednesday, December 21, 2016
My 16: 2016's Top Theatrical Experiences
![]() |
| James Ortiz and Eliza Martin Simpson in The Woodsman. Photo by Matthew Murphy. |
My overall play-going count is a bit lower than it's been since I started these posts - 122 plays total, with 11 repeats, which leaves us with 111 unique shows for the year. I'm not enough of a statistician and too lazy a researcher to look at the volume of how many shows were produced this year to comment further, but I'll try to comfort all of us by saying that the list I've made of shows to see for the spring season of 2017 is terrifyingly dense. As usual, for the purposes of this list, I am not including any shows I saw in earlier years (so while yes, I did see both Hamilton and Bedlam's Sense and Sensibility in 2016 and adored them to pieces, they topped my 2015 and 2014 lists respectively, and don't get to be included again).
One further note before I begin: I'm writing this list without having yet seen the final two shows on my 2016 docket - the pre-Broadway run of Amélie in Los Angeles and NYGASP's The Mikado. If it turns out I've made a huge mistake in omitting either, I'm making a note now to include them next year.
Let's go!
Monday, December 21, 2015
15 for '15 - My Top Theatrical Experiences This Year
![]() |
| Daniel N. Durant as Moritz in Deaf West's Spring Awakening. Photo by Kevin Parry. |
Monday, December 29, 2014
14 for '14! My Top Theater Picks
![]() |
| Firdous Bamji, Romola Garai, and Brenda Meaney in Indian Ink. Photo by Joan Marcus. |
So without further ado, here are my Top 14 for '14!
Monday, December 23, 2013
The Best Theater of 2013 (in my own humble whatever)
Well, the year is winding down, which means retrospections are in order. As a self-proclaimed theater junkie, I try to see as much theater as I can manage, time- and funds-wise. And this year I've been extraordinarily lucky. I went through my calendar and programs, and - not counting any repeats, like the fact that I saw Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812 three times, by the end of 2013 I will have seen 122 different plays/musicals/theatrical whatnots. 122. That means that, on average, every three days I saw a new show. You guys.So I'm pretty pleased with myself, I'm not gonna lie to you. And I saw a lot of good theater. A LOT. Some thrilling, some heartbreaking, some hilarious, some huge spectacles, and some small intimate affairs. Boiling down the list to my favorites was very, very hard. First I took out any production that had premiered prior to 2013. That helped ... eliminate 10 shows. All right, then I really got to work. I couldn't include every amazing show, or good-enough shows that had amazing moments in them. But these listed below were the top shows that really blew me away, in one way or another.
And, in honor of its being 2013 (and my inability to narrow my list down to 10), here are my top 13 theatrical adventures of 2013:






























